A guide to what to do and where to go!

Best Oysters Restaurants in Annapolis

O'Learys Seafood Restaurant

Table of Contents

Nestled on the Chesapeake Bay, Annapolis is a haven for seafood lovers, especially those with a penchant for oysters. The city’s rich maritime heritage and access to fresh seafood make it an ideal destination for indulging in this delectable shellfish. In this guide, we will explore the best oyster restaurants in Annapolis, offering you a comprehensive look at where to find the finest oysters, what makes these restaurants stand out, and how to enjoy your oyster dining experience to the fullest.

The Charm of Annapolis Seafood

Annapolis, Maryland’s capital, boasts a vibrant culinary scene deeply influenced by its coastal location. The city’s restaurants are renowned for their commitment to fresh, locally-sourced seafood, with oysters taking center stage. These bivalves are a staple in Annapolis, and the local waters provide a perfect habitat for them to thrive. This proximity to fresh oysters ensures that restaurants can serve the highest quality shellfish, bursting with flavor and freshness.

Factors that Define a Top Oyster Restaurant

When it comes to choosing the best oyster restaurants, several factors come into play. These include the freshness and quality of the oysters, the variety offered, the skill of the chefs in preparing them, and the overall dining experience. Ambiance, service, and sustainability practices also significantly influence the overall appeal of an oyster restaurant.

O’Learys Seafood Restaurant

Located in Eastport, O’Learys Seafood Restaurant is a standout choice for oyster aficionados. Known for its elegant setting and exceptional seafood, O’Learys offers a wide variety of oysters sourced from local waters. The chefs here are adept at showcasing the natural flavors of the oysters, whether served raw, grilled, or baked.

Cantler’s Riverside Inn

Cantler’s Riverside Inn is a beloved institution in Annapolis, famous for its rustic charm and riverside location. This family-owned establishment has been serving fresh oysters for decades, earning a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. The oysters at Cantler’s are often enjoyed on picnic tables overlooking the water, creating an unforgettable dining experience.

Carrol’s Creek Cafe

Overlooking Spa Creek, Carrol’s Creek Cafe is another top destination for oyster lovers. This waterfront restaurant is known for its stunning views and sophisticated menu, featuring an array of oyster dishes. The oysters here are meticulously sourced and expertly prepared, offering a true taste of Annapolis’ seafood bounty.

Middleton Tavern

Steeped in history, Middleton Tavern has been serving Annapolis residents since the 18th century. This historic tavern is famous for its oysters, which are a highlight of the menu. Whether you prefer them raw on the half shell or incorporated into a more elaborate dish, Middleton Tavern offers an authentic taste of Annapolis’ oyster heritage.

Severn Inn

The Severn Inn offers breathtaking views of the Severn River and the U.S. Naval Academy, paired with a menu that celebrates the best of Chesapeake Bay seafood. Their oysters are a particular highlight, often featured in creative preparations that highlight their fresh, briny flavors.

Chart House

Part of a well-known chain, the Chart House in Annapolis delivers a consistently high-quality dining experience. The restaurant’s prime waterfront location and elegant decor make it a popular choice for special occasions. Their oysters, sourced both locally and from other prime locations, are served with inventive accompaniments that enhance their natural taste.

Boatyard Bar & Grill

For a more casual but equally satisfying oyster experience, the Boatyard Bar & Grill is a fantastic option. This lively spot is popular among sailors and seafood lovers alike. The oysters are always fresh and can be enjoyed in a relaxed, nautical-themed setting.

Factors to Consider When Choosing an Oyster Restaurant

When selecting an oyster restaurant, consider the following: the source and sustainability of the oysters, the variety and preparation methods offered, the expertise of the chefs, the restaurant’s reputation, and the overall dining environment. A great oyster restaurant will not only serve delicious oysters but also provide an ambiance that enhances your dining experience.

Sustainable Seafood Practices in Annapolis

Sustainability is a crucial aspect of seafood dining, and many Annapolis restaurants are committed to responsible sourcing practices. This ensures that the oyster populations remain healthy and that future generations can continue to enjoy these delicious shellfish. Look for restaurants that emphasize local, sustainable seafood on their menus.

Local Oyster Varieties and Their Unique Flavors

Annapolis is home to several oyster varieties, each offering unique flavors influenced by their growing conditions. The most common varieties include the Chesapeake Bay oyster, known for its mild, sweet flavor, and the Rappahannock oyster, which is slightly saltier. Exploring these different varieties can be a delightful culinary adventure.

The Role of Ambiance in Dining Experience

The ambiance of a restaurant can significantly impact your dining experience. In Annapolis, many oyster restaurants boast stunning waterfront views, historic settings, or charming nautical decor. These elements combine to create a memorable dining experience that goes beyond just the food.

Special Events and Oyster Festivals in Annapolis

Annapolis hosts several oyster festivals and special events throughout the year, celebrating this beloved shellfish. These events are an excellent opportunity to sample a wide variety of oysters, learn more about oyster farming and sustainability, and enjoy live music and other entertainment.

Best Time of Year to Enjoy Oysters in Annapolis

While oysters can be enjoyed year-round, they are often at their best during the cooler months. The adage “R” months (those with an ‘R’ in their name: September through April) traditionally marks the peak oyster season, when the oysters are plump and flavorful.

Health Benefits of Eating Oysters

Oysters are not only delicious but also packed with nutrients. They are an excellent source of protein, omega-3 fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals such as zinc and iron. Regular consumption of oysters can support heart health, boost the immune system, and contribute to overall wellness.

Wine Pairings with Oysters

Pairing oysters with the right wine can elevate the dining experience. Crisp, acidic wines such as Chablis, Sauvignon Blanc, and Champagne complement the briny, delicate flavors of oysters. Each variety of oyster may pair best with a specific type of wine, so don’t hesitate to ask your server for recommendations.

Cooking Styles and Preparation Methods

Oysters can be enjoyed in various ways, each method bringing out different flavors and textures. Raw oysters are a classic choice, offering a pure taste of the sea. Grilled, baked, or fried oysters provide a different culinary experience, often accompanied by delicious sauces and toppings.

Testimonials and Reviews from Oyster Lovers

Customer reviews and testimonials can provide valuable insights into the quality of an oyster restaurant. Many diners in Annapolis share their experiences online, offering recommendations and highlighting what makes each restaurant special. These reviews can guide you to the best spots in town.

Tips for the Perfect Oyster Experience

To fully enjoy your oyster dining experience, consider these tips: Start with raw oysters to appreciate their natural flavor, experiment with different sauces and accompaniments, and try a variety of oyster preparations. Don’t forget to savor the ambiance and enjoy the company you’re with.

The Future of Oyster Farming in Annapolis

Oyster farming is an essential part of Annapolis’ economy and ecosystem. Advances in sustainable farming practices are ensuring that oyster populations remain healthy and abundant. Supporting restaurants that prioritize local, sustainably-farmed oysters helps preserve this vital industry for future generations.


How do I know if an oyster is fresh?

Fresh oysters should have a clean, ocean-like smell and a tightly closed shell. When opened, the oyster should be plump and filled with clear, briny liquid.

What are the best months to eat oysters in Annapolis?

Oysters are typically at their best during the cooler months, from September to April, when they are plump and flavorful.

Can I find non-seafood options at these restaurants?

Yes, most oyster restaurants in Annapolis offer a variety of non-seafood dishes to cater to different tastes and dietary preferences.

What should I pair with oysters for the best dining experience?

Crisp, acidic wines such as Sauvignon Blanc or Champagne pair excellently with oysters. Light beers and sparkling water are also good options.

Are oyster shells recyclable?

Yes, many oyster shells are recycled and used in oyster reef restoration projects. These projects help to rebuild oyster populations and improve water quality.

Do oyster restaurants in Annapolis accommodate dietary restrictions?

Most restaurants are accommodating of dietary restrictions and offer options or modifications to meet your needs. It’s always best to inform your server of any specific requirements.


Annapolis offers a rich and diverse selection of oyster restaurants, each bringing something unique to the table. From historic taverns to modern waterfront eateries, there is no shortage of places to enjoy fresh, delicious oysters. By choosing restaurants that prioritize sustainability and quality, you can savor the best that Annapolis has to offer while supporting local seafood practices. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the oyster dining experience in Annapolis is not to be missed.


More to explorer